The results? You'll have to check out boston.com's gallery for the full rankings and comments, but some local favorites had some surprising results. Harpoon, which carries a line of great specialty beers, did not fare very well in this tasting, and Sam Adams got a middling rating. New Hampshire's Smuttynose did very well. Maine's Shipyard received a split decision for its two pumpkin selections.
Are you a fan of pumpkin beer, or are they too sweet and cinnamon-y for you? Tell us in the comments section below.