patching...
Update: Don't "like" Malden Patch on Facebook? What are you thinking?! Click here to get Malden's headlines in your newsfeed, as they happen. »
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

City Announces Changes to "Pay As You Throw"

"Short term" solutions are aimed at mitigating some resident complaints about the program.

 

The City of Malden website reported some changes to the "Pay As You Throw" program that took effect this week, including the introduction of smaller bags for consumers who use less trash. 

New eight gallon bags will be sold at .50 a piece at all outlets where blue bags are available, the city release read. Residents will also be able to buy a smaller 5-pack of bags. 

The new blue bags, along with the 33-gallon and 15-gallon varieties, will be shipped directly to stores, with none available at the Department of Public Works or Treasurer's office. 

The city release noted these were "short term" solutions to the problems facing the "Pay As You Throw" program, started by Mayor Richard Howard in 2008. 

Mayor Gary Christenson told readers in his monthly Malden Patch online chat last month that his administration was "working on a way to eliminate the blue bags." 

He encouraged readers to use covered trash bins to help keep the city cleaner.

Check out this YouTube video provided by Ward 7 Councilor Neal Anderson, who teamed up with Bobby Knox and Ron Zanazzo of the Malden Department of Public Works to help show residents how to properly recycle and contain trash.

Related Topics: Pay As You Throw

TG's Mom

7:40 am on Tuesday, March 6, 2012

Has there been any consideration of passing along the blue recycle bins similar to what Everett & Medford offer to their residents? Also, is there anyway to reduce the amount of the 15 gal bags?

Reply
Comment_arrow
Patch_comments_icon

Chris Caesar

10:13 am on Tuesday, March 6, 2012

What do you mean by "reducing the amount of them," TG's Mom?

Alethia B.

8:25 am on Tuesday, March 6, 2012

All the surrounding towns have a large recycling container and a small trash bin that can be wheeled to the sidewalk. I was once told by someone at the City Yard that Malden will never get them so basically get use to the trash bags. It is just a way for Malden Politicians to “continue” double dipping. I have my fingers crossed that Mayor Christenson will take a “serious” look at revamping the trash system.
There have been times when I had to spend my last $20 on trash bags and eat soup for dinner. I would like to pay a onetime fee, whatever that may be to just have a sturdy trash bin.
We need a “long” term solution.

Reply
Comment_arrow

coldwaterdiver

9:57 am on Thursday, March 8, 2012

They used to call that "Taxes"

E vietro

9:02 am on Tuesday, March 6, 2012

When/if we go to trash barrels and recycling bins as may be recommended. I hope the trash disposal companies are more kind with the trash barrels as they roll all over all the streets they are used in. Most households have all adults working during the day. There is no one to put the barrels back on the sidewalks. They also toss the covers like frisbees left to their own way to get back to the owner. Updating the system definitely needs to be done, but the contractors need to be updated on their end. I have seen many "near accidents" as cars try to avoid trash barrels in the street even on non windy days.

Reply

Stephen Roeder

9:20 am on Tuesday, March 6, 2012

Nobody likes fees and taxes and the Pay as You Throw Program is no different. Unfortunately, trash removal to be paid for, some way or another. Pay as You Throw allows residents to have some control over how much they pay for their trash removal and it helps distribute the cost more fairly to those residents that produce the most trash. Homeowners alone, aren't forced to bear the entire burden through higher property taxes, just because they own a home.

Reply
Comment_arrow

DannyBoy

9:54 am on Tuesday, March 6, 2012

Stephen, if you want to talk about fairness to Malden residents about PAYT, then the city should make this program mandatory to ALL residents. As of today, dwellings that have more than six units are EXEMPT from this program (i.e. large apartment and condo buildings), you can see it for yourself, as it's spelled out on the city's website.

Comment_arrow

coldwaterdiver

10:01 am on Thursday, March 8, 2012

"D", those large buildings are required to have independent trash removal. You are right to a point though, any city housing, (elderly and low income developments) do not use the blue bags. So its not fair to all residents. Basically this was a money making scheme that didnt make the money it was supposed to. And dont forget, our new mayor was on the city council when our old mayor snuck this in the back door.

Anticrooks

10:05 am on Tuesday, March 6, 2012

So paying for the trash bags is not enough, now they want us to buy barrels? what's next? All the cities around us have huge recycling containers provided by the city, that accommodate all the recycling needs. They are heaving enough not to get blown away on windy days, why can't Malden do the same. We don't mind paying for the stupid trash bag if they can at least provide the recycling containers. I wonder why many people are leaving Malden.

Reply
Comment_arrow

coldwaterdiver

10:01 am on Thursday, March 8, 2012

Funny, almost everyone I knew from High School has left town.

maldenmom148

10:27 am on Tuesday, March 6, 2012

D: You are correct when you say large apartment and condo buildings are exempt from the PAYT program, but keep in mind, they must pay for the dumpsters that are on their site, and who pays for that? The condominium owner. So no one is exempt from paying for trash pick up.

Reply
Comment_arrow

DannyBoy

11:30 am on Tuesday, March 6, 2012

Well, I don't agree with this logic. The condo owner still has to pay taxes, just like I do as a homeowner, except for the fact that the dumpster is used for the convenience of the residents of the building (i.e. they could use regular trash barrils to store their trash instead, like I do). Nobody is disputing the fact that WE ALL pay for the trash pick up service, but the PAYT program is penalizing those residents that do not live in the large apartment and condo buildings.

Comment_arrow

coldwaterdiver

10:03 am on Thursday, March 8, 2012

"So no one is exempt from paying for trash pick up" Except anyone living in one of the many subsidized housing developments. What percentage of Malden is subsidized anyway, 20%.....30%?

Comment_arrow

Diana

2:30 pm on Saturday, March 10, 2012

coldwaterdiver, 11.4% of Malden Housing is subsidized. You're welcome.
http://www.massaffordablehomes.org/mahamap.html

Homeowner

10:38 am on Tuesday, March 6, 2012

The "new" system has forced me to recycle more, which is a good thing, although dragging 3 barrels to the curb every week is not fun (paper, plastic, trash). I think Revere's system of using one big barrel with a cover for any and all recycled materials is better. When the recycle barrel is picked up, the barrel is scanned and you get credit for recycling by giving the owner "points" which can be used towards the purchase of items at local merchants.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Marc Levine

1:00 pm on Saturday, March 10, 2012

Sounds like a plan Homeowner

Comment_arrow

J

11:29 pm on Sunday, March 11, 2012

Malden has been allowing comingled recycling for quite some time now.

Comment_arrow

Bobby James

9:02 am on Monday, March 12, 2012

@Jazz Snowden - there's a big difference between single stream and co-mingled. Malden allows for co-mingled for non-paper based recyclables, but all the towns around us support single stream.

Anon

11:00 am on Tuesday, March 6, 2012

I walk by about two dozen homes on my way to work every morning.
Before PAYT, I'd see three, may four recycle bins on the curb on trash day.
After PAYT I see one, maybe two homes a week without a recycle bin on the curb.
Extrapolate across the city and that is a whole lot of recycling going on.

I understand people's distaste for PAYT, (buying the bags is a pain + one more expense) but it has been a success in my eyes.

Now, about getting recycle bins that don't crack after the first month of use...

Reply

E

11:25 am on Tuesday, March 6, 2012

Get us the bigger recycle bins and get rid of these stupid trash bags! If you want us to recycle, help us

Reply
Comment_arrow

Anon

12:39 pm on Tuesday, March 6, 2012

E,

The reason the PATY works so well is that it provides a financial disincentive for not recycling.

As much as I would like to believe that people will always do the right thing if given the proper tools, the sad fact is money is a much more powerful motivator.

Kelly Ilebode

4:05 pm on Tuesday, March 6, 2012

I still use my "old" white trash bags then pile them into 1 large blue trash bag. 3 times someone dumped out my trash and took my blue trash bags. On several other occasions the recycle people didn't take my paper recycling because there were cans in the paper...the non-redeemable cans were not left by me....the whole program needs to be revamped....I spoke with the DPW and there only comment was "don't put your trash out the night before trash day..." *sigh*

Reply
Comment_arrow

DannyBoy

4:37 pm on Tuesday, March 6, 2012

Kelly, that's why the blue bags have to go, as you found out the hard way, some unscrupulous people are going around stealing them, abusing the system and not understanding how recycling works.

Comment_arrow

J

11:31 pm on Sunday, March 11, 2012

But... you're NOT supposed to put your trash out the night before. In addition to what you experienced, animals scrounge through your trash too which creates a gigantic mess all over the street. The JRM guys don't pick that stuff up.

Jen Laughton

4:30 pm on Tuesday, March 6, 2012

I recycle so much ! I have 3 recycle bins, that overflow, every week. It's just those trash bags, I live with myself, husband, and two kids, and have to use 2, and sometimes 3, trash bags. And those are the 2$ bags.

I say take away the blue trash bags, and make it mandatory that we recycle, and fine the residents that don't. It might sound like a hassle, but if we do our job, the trash collectors could give off some type of fine. anything is possible of we put our minds to it.

Reply
Comment_arrow

DannyBoy

4:31 pm on Tuesday, March 6, 2012

Jen, how are you going to get City Hall to write out those fines to residents that don't recycle? That's going to be another layer of bureaucratic nightmare that taxpayers will have to dish out for, and I'm of the mind of keeping things simple and not wanting to waste any more of our taxpayer dollars to local bureaucrats!

Kelly Ilebode

5:02 pm on Tuesday, March 6, 2012

I applaud you Jen for trying to come up with a different solution! and I have to say my recycling did improve having had to buy the bags...BUT .I didn't like it in the beginning and dislike it even more now with the economy the way it is...times are hard enough as it is without having to shell out $10/$20 box of bags that fall apart...

Reply

paul surette

5:11 pm on Tuesday, March 6, 2012

Awesome...a tutorial on how to throw out one's trash. Boy, do I feel enlightened! Who knew walking out to the curb, opening up the lid, and throwing the trash in the barrel was so complicated!

Reply
Comment_arrow
Patch_comments_icon

Chris Caesar

5:29 pm on Tuesday, March 6, 2012

Sure seems to elude some people!

paul surette

5:25 pm on Tuesday, March 6, 2012

Funny how Medford doesn't make their residents buy those expensive trash bags. As a matter of fact, Medford supplies their residents with a full size barrel for trash AND one for recycling. And they still do it all for a lot cheaper. Makes you wonder where the money for the bags really goes. Someone call Carl Bernstein!

Reply

paul surette

5:35 pm on Tuesday, March 6, 2012

Mr Bob Knox, is your employment recyclable? :)

Reply

richard snyder

5:44 pm on Tuesday, March 6, 2012

the city of everett also has a barrel for recycling papers, cans ans plastics, and they give there residents points on different things within the city.. why hasnt someone from malden checked with them on how there program works and the city streets in everett are a hell of lot cleaner on trash days than maldens... I know i have lived in both citys, the trash man in everett dont leave the trash on the street where they drop it......

Reply

Kelly Ilebode

5:50 pm on Tuesday, March 6, 2012

If I remember correctly the contract is almost up with this trash company.?!...maybe time to review and not renew?

Reply
Comment_arrow

Bobby James

8:39 am on Wednesday, March 7, 2012

Howard made sure to re-up with incompetent JRM before he left. Real sweetheart deal for 20 years.
https://imageserv3.team-logic.com/mediaLibrary/181/Malden_CAFR_2011_1.pdf
Page 69

Comment_arrow

stella

10:57 pm on Thursday, March 8, 2012

Kelly, I dont know if this is true or not but i heard that the former mayor howard renewed the trash companys contract for 20 years. Again i dont know for sure if this is true or not.

Comment_arrow

DannyBoy

7:49 am on Friday, March 9, 2012

mad dog, it is true: just read page 69 of the document that you can access from the link sent by Bobby James, it's in writing, plain and clear.

Jen Laughton

8:20 pm on Tuesday, March 6, 2012

Kelly I couldn't agree with you more! I return my soda cans and bottles for my money. And then recycle everything else, recyclable. I just feel that as a resident of Malden, i don't feel I should have to pay to throw my trash away. There is complexes like bowdoin who have dumpsters and they don't have to buy those bags. And what kills me is as I'm struggling with the bad economy, paying for these bags, and watching Malden City Workers, driving around in their pretty much new Suburbans....and in the summer got the windows up blasting the AC's. ......hmmm, are we paying the gas for those semi-new trucks?

Reply

Bobby James

8:47 am on Wednesday, March 7, 2012

I find the headline of "Changes to PAYT" misleading. They announced a new bag size, nothing changed.

Reply
Comment_arrow
Patch_comments_icon

Chris Caesar

8:49 am on Wednesday, March 7, 2012

I see your point Bobby, but they are also selling bags in smaller packs and in different places. The sub headline makes note that administration considers them "short term" solutions, and have pledged more changes down the road.

Comment_arrow

DannyBoy

9:48 am on Wednesday, March 7, 2012

Thanks for that link Bobby. It just goes to show you what a "legacy" King Howard has left this city with. JRM's service is pretty bad, so how can this administration get out of that contract? I cannot imagine this city's residents having to put up with JRM for another 20-something years!

Comment_arrow

coldwaterdiver

10:08 am on Thursday, March 8, 2012

Remember people, PAYT was not designed to address trash removal. It was designed to make the city money. They were pretty much up front with that.

Kelly Ilebode

10:06 am on Wednesday, March 7, 2012

OMG! I didn't realize that about the contract :( as far as the recyclables Jen, The "non recyclable" cans were left several times in my paper because of the people that walk around collecting recyclable cans and emptying in MY paper bin their garbage. (Caught them several times doing this) Which is why the DPW told me to put my "stuff" out in the morning....to prevent this. Putting items out in the morning hasn't prevented this at all because I have to take my kids to school and now I don't "catch" them doing it. *Sigh* losing battle...

Reply

troia

5:08 pm on Wednesday, March 7, 2012

Since this program started this city has been looking like the city dump !!

Reply

Rachel B

5:25 pm on Wednesday, March 7, 2012

I know that as a parent of two small children in diapers, our garbage is extensive. Our disposable diapers take up at least one big bag. What makes the PAYT program hard for us is the cost of bags coupled with the terrible quality of the bags! They rip, tear and are not designed for heavy or large items even though they are large bags. It is difficult to be faced with the dilemma of having to "afford" to throw away your garbage. It feels unfair that on top of a lagging economy young families in need of support are faced with economic pressure from the very towns that are taking their hard earned taxes.

Reply

coldwaterdiver

10:12 am on Thursday, March 8, 2012

The city of Gloucester used to have a sticker program, same idea as the bags, only you get to choose the bags you want, and put a sticker on anything non recycleable. But really, trash removal is an essential service, on that our city taxes, (which seem pretty high considering my house as lost 20% of its value) had historically payed for. Now that the city council and former mayor has brought in this new revenue stream, you can count on it being here forever.

Reply

Joe Gray

4:48 pm on Thursday, March 8, 2012

Not assisting this revenue stream. Guessing the city "isn't" making the kind of revenue off of this that they thought they would. Never bought a blue trash bag. Never intend to.

Reply

Raj

12:16 pm on Saturday, March 10, 2012

Even if you do everything right and put out your recycle bins and used the blue bags, the quality of the bags has been getting thinner and thinner with the drawstring almost like its perforated..so the bags break either just by filling them or when neighborhood dogs or scavengers for cans break into them. Then there is the fact that most weeks JRM does not pick up the recycle bins at the same time as the trash bags, so the trash blows around all day. Then there is JRM themselves. If they have a mishap when collecting bags or bins and drop trash into the street, they do not pick it up! I don't know why the city contracts with JRM when they have plenty of city workers sitting in Honey Dew donuts on Eastern Avenue every morning around 9:30am!

The only solution to Malden's trash problem is get rid of the blue bags and go back to a local based solution to collect the trash, where the people that work collecting the trash have pride in the city for giving them employment and accountability as well.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Marc Levine

12:48 pm on Saturday, March 10, 2012

So Raj you would like it to go back to the way it was before the blue bags when there was no incentive to recycle. The incentive is they save money on not having to buy so many blue bags. Get rid of blue bags, good idea. Go back to the way it was before, bad idea. A different system the Mayor is trying to come up with, excellent idea.

Comment_arrow

Marc Levine

11:30 am on Monday, March 12, 2012

930 am is their break time. Whether you want them to have one at this time is a different story. It's been this way for as long as I can remember. Got a complaint with JRM call them directly. I do and they ALWAYS correct the problem.

Comment_arrow

smpolli

8:08 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012

Raj..there are city employees at Honey Dew at that time of the morning because it is there scheduled coffee break. Union contracts allow them 2 breaks and a lunch period. That has nothing to do with the fact that the JRM employees are irresponsible when picking up the trash and recycling. I agree the bag quality is poor and they also take no care with the recycle bins. It is though a city ordinance that the trash bags be put out in barrels, it was always on the website, not sure if it still is ..which in the long run helps the city animals stay out of the bags. I am all for getting rid of the bags and going to barrels though.

paul surette

6:02 pm on Saturday, March 10, 2012

Word up on that, Raj....if the city workers aren't sitting at either Dunkin' Donuts or Honey Dew, they are parked at Anthony's on Canal Street for an 'extended' lunch. Dear Mr. Levine.....the blue trash bags came AFTER the recycling bins came to fruition ! But I'm sure you knew that :)

Reply
Comment_arrow

Marc Levine

6:28 pm on Saturday, March 10, 2012

I knew that. There has to be a better way to recycle instead of the bins. The bins were okay when people did not recycle that much (before the blue bags:) But now that we have the bags (or in the future something different) we need bigger containers that have lids. Don't plan on the old way anytime soon. In Melrose they pay a flat fee of $200 a year for a one family and $400.00 a year for a two family. My buddy lives alone and he recycles. He may have one small bag a week after recycling everything he does.

Comment_arrow

J

11:38 pm on Sunday, March 11, 2012

"In Melrose they pay a flat fee of $200 a year for a one family"

Given that each 33-gallon bag is $2, (10-pack for $20), you would be using about 100 33-gallon trash bags a year at that rate, which is just about 2 33-gallon bags a week.

That's a lot of trash...

stella

10:06 am on Sunday, March 11, 2012

I feel the residents of MALDEN would continue to recycle if city hall got rid of the blue bags. The only difference between the city bags and the green hefty bags we used to use is PRICE. They are both biodegradeable. WHY dosen't city hall let the residents go back to the old way for one month and in that month if nothing has changed then keep the blue bags.

Reply

Marc Levine

12:26 pm on Sunday, March 11, 2012

It's human nature more times then not, if you are not forced or if there is no direct benefit to you, your not going to do it. (as far as recycling goes) The mayor and his team are trying to "build a better mouse trap" It's not going to happen over night. So until the new mouse trap is built we are going to have to deal with what we have. Reply at will.......

Reply

DannyBoy

1:07 pm on Sunday, March 11, 2012

As the residents of Malden have become more diverse over the years, it would be helpful to the city and its residents if they made instruction videos in a language other than English, as there are more and more non-native English speakers in this city. Case in point: the tenants, who live in the multi-family house next door, are Chinese, speak Mandarin, and they don't seem to quite get this whole trash/recycling thing.

Reply

Marc Levine

11:26 am on Monday, March 12, 2012

Well folks.....I am going to leave this in the hands of the powers to be an see what happens. Hopefully a different system will be the answer. It's not going to happen over night, so be patient. Also you can't please all of the people all of the time. With that in mind, I'm done debating this issue. Waiting for the next........8)

Reply

Deanna MacMillan

1:18 pm on Saturday, March 17, 2012

I asked about the bags at Stop and Shop yesterday, and they had no clue about this change.. Does anyone know where I can find them??

Reply
Comment_arrow

DannyBoy

2:32 pm on Saturday, March 17, 2012

Deanna, your best bet is to call DPW and find that information from them.

MaldenWasGreat

12:39 pm on Thursday, May 3, 2012

any idea why the bags can't be purchased at city hall or the city yards anymore?

Reply
Comment_arrow

DannyBoy

1:05 pm on Thursday, May 3, 2012

No idea why, but you can always call and ask DPW or City Hall.

Bobby James

8:37 am on Friday, June 15, 2012

Here's one for ya - looks like good ole Richie Howard is still in bed with JRM:
http://www.boston.com/yourtown/news/arlington/2012/06/arlington_placing_limits_on_tr.html?p1=Well_Local_YourTownlinks

"The first change will come July 2 when the town’s new contractor, Peabody-based JRM Hauling and Recycling, will begin picking up recycling every week instead of every other week. Seasonal pickup of yard waste will also move to a weekly schedule."

Thanks for that sweethart 20 year deal on your way out when you didn't give a crap about anything else, Richie. JRM obviously has good ole Richie in their pocket, or on their payroll.

Reply

Leave a comment